We're new to the forum/site (and love them!) but not to Cozumel.
This past February we tried Coctelito and had a "nice enough" meal and would probably try it again.
That said, we noticed a place across the road, on the water, and had a fantastic experience. We had to kind of leap from the sea wall to it's balcony/enterance. Ah the gool 'ol Cozumel!
We're headed back in a couple of weeks. Does anyone know the name? If it's still there?
Ed & Leslie